Cydonia

hystericali

easy question really, if you had to give Muse CD to a non Muse fan what would it be and why?

I suppose the most obvious one to me is BHaR, not because its the most recent, but I think its their most (for want of a better expression) 'commercial' and most 'easily accessible' CD. Its the easiest CD to listen to, OOS would be my choice because its my favourite, but Citizen Erased and Space Dementia might be a bit much for the non fan! BHaR is a 'gentle' introduction to the world of Muse. I'd then give them Absolution, OOS and finally Showbiz.

_________________

**********************************
MUSE CALENDAR 2006/07
27th August 2006 - Leeds Festival
17th November 2006 - Nottingham Arena
18th November 2006 - Sheffield Arena
16th June 2007 - WEMBLEY STADIUM
**********************************

tasheh · Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2007 12:21 am Post subject:

It a really tough one. I personally wouldn't give them BH&R because I think its not a good representation of their music. I'd probably make a compilation of songs and then that person can choose what album they'd prefer to listen to first from it.
_________________
London Earl's Court 19/12/04
Nottingham Ice Arena 17/11/06
London Wembley Stadium 16/06/07
London Wembley Stadium 17/06/07
Paris Parc des Princes 23/06/07
Old Ice Hall, Helsinki, Finland 17/10/07

hystericali · Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2007 8:19 am Post subject:

good answer! But at the moment I can only offer her an entire CD

I'm trying to get a friend to understand that Muse aren't, to use her word 'awful'. Matt's 'screeching' at the end of Plug In Baby put her off.

She needs educating

_________________

**********************************
MUSE CALENDAR 2006/07
27th August 2006 - Leeds Festival
17th November 2006 - Nottingham Arena
18th November 2006 - Sheffield Arena
16th June 2007 - WEMBLEY STADIUM
**********************************

Helen · Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2007 9:17 am Post subject:

I would say Absolution - coz thats what did it for me! I was not a fan before I heard that album, now love all of em.

wildflower · Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2007 9:34 am Post subject:

i would have to say a compilation too, thats how i got my friend into them! she didnt like matts "screechyness" much either, but i carefully chose songs in which he didnt scream too much and she ended up loving his voice and demanded more songs hehe! eventually she just went out and bought everything! i think once they are introduced to the non screechy matt, then they fall in love with that voice and they then take anything they can get their hands on

_________________

"I can argue very well. Ask any of my remaining friends. I can win an argument on any topic, against any opponent. People know this, and steer clear of me at parties. Often, as a sign of their great respect, they don't even invite me."

tasheh · Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2007 11:08 am Post subject:

Hmm.. yeah the screechyness is a hard one to come by... I know several people who are like that... then yeah I would offer BH&R because he dosn't concentrate on his voice so much in these songs...
_________________
London Earl's Court 19/12/04
Nottingham Ice Arena 17/11/06
London Wembley Stadium 16/06/07
London Wembley Stadium 17/06/07
Paris Parc des Princes 23/06/07
Old Ice Hall, Helsinki, Finland 17/10/07

hystericali · Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2007 12:46 pm Post subject:

people either love his voice or hate it, there seems to be no 'oh its ok' with Matt's vocals!
_________________

**********************************
MUSE CALENDAR 2006/07
27th August 2006 - Leeds Festival
17th November 2006 - Nottingham Arena
18th November 2006 - Sheffield Arena
16th June 2007 - WEMBLEY STADIUM
**********************************

Ham of the Problematique · Posted: Thu Apr 19, 2007 3:57 pm Post subject:

It's the marmite theory. I would have to say Absolution too, I think that that is actually the most accessible of all their albums and it has some harder and softer stuff on it. It was their first really popular album too. Also I don't think that the vocals on there are particularly screechy.
_________________
Keeper of Matthew's hands...

ashentara · Posted: Wed May 02, 2007 10:29 am Post subject:

I'd go with Showbiz
it's the rawest album, you know
yeah I can understand you either love Matt's voice or hate it.. but there are songs on that album.. well if you really don't like them, no way you're gonna like later Muse

_________________

Haytch · Muse Fan Joined: 22 Jun 2007 Posts: 145

I would have to say Absolution too! I was a fan before this came out but no where near once Absolution was released. I'd want someone to get into them with older stuff, not because there is a new album out and played on the radio every day.
_________________

Fury · Posted: Mon Jul 16, 2007 4:01 pm Post subject:

Difficult question..I can't decide.Absolution or BHAR? :roll: :| :alien:
But I would choose BHAR.These songs are not so Rocky as Absolution songs are :mrgreen: and then I would give Absolution :mrgreen:
_________________

After8 · Muse Fan Joined: 10 Jul 2007 Posts: 38 Location: Lithuania

Careful, month long harrassement over Skype, one hand-picked song at a time..

_________________
My favourite album by The Muses is Black Revelations and Hole.